Why Theory is the Key to Mastering Your Blind Tasting Skills
- Jessica Waugh
- May 28
- 4 min read
Many sommeliers and wine enthusiasts focus on blind tasting repeatedly, hoping that by sheer luck, they’ll eventually hone their skills. But this approach lacks depth. Without a solid understanding of the theory behind deductive tasting, you’re missing a crucial step in truly mastering the craft.
To be a great taster, you need to understand the theory behind the wines you’re tasting, not just rely on guesswork. In fact, if you can memorize the grand crus of Burgundy, you should be equally capable of memorizing key characteristics of wines from around the world. For instance, you should be able to recall the white wines that are typically high in acid, the reds known for their high tannin levels, and which whites usually see oak. When this theoretical foundation is in your memory, the tasting process becomes far more streamlined.
Deductive Tasting: Connecting the Dots
When you understand the theory behind wines, your initial conclusion during a blind tasting isn’t just based on random guessing—it’s grounded in knowledge. For example, if a wine presents itself with certain "tells," such as high acid or a particular aromatic component, you can immediately narrow down the possibilities to a few options. Once you identify the initial group, you dive deeper into the specific attributes of the wine to make the final, accurate conclusion.
This process doesn’t require a glass of wine in front of you. By creating flashcards for wines with specific structural components, you’re training your brain to recognize which wines belong together in an initial deduction. Knowing which players to bring in is key to making your tasting process more efficient. As Jay Fletcher, a mentor of mine, always said, “You can't get the wine right if you don't bring in all the players.”
Fine-Tuning Your Tasting Skills
A great analogy for improving your deductive tasting is how sports professionals rewatch their plays and fine-tune their performance. In wine tasting, this can be done through blind tastings paired with self-assessment. Record yourself tasting, then listen back and grade your performance. I provide grading sheets for classic wines on my website to help you assess your own progress. This feedback loop allows you to identify where you’re getting it right—and where you’re making missteps.
For example, when I was learning, Châteauneuf-du-Pape (CDP) was my nemesis. I often mistook it for Zinfandel, Sangiovese, or New World Pinot Noir—few of which made theoretical sense. So, I created a comparative tasting plan, blind tasting these wines side by side, then listening to my analysis and grading myself. This single-blind exercise allowed me to recognize the subtle nuances that distinguished CDP from other wines. It was through this method that I honed my skills and became the best taster I’d ever been.
Practice Doesn’t Require Wine in Front of You
One of the best exercises I did with my study partner was a game we played at a local Mexican restaurant over chips and beer. One person would think of a wine, and the other had five questions to ask in order to guess it. The beauty of this exercise is that you don’t need wine in front of you to practice. You can narrow down the possibilities quickly and it’s amazing how few wines require more than three strategic questions to identify.
For example, let's say I’m a red wine. The first question could be: "Does the wine have new oak?"
Answer: No – This immediately narrows the options down to wines like Beaujolais, Chinon, Châteauneuf-du-Pape (CDP), Northern Rhône Syrah, Sangiovese, Nebbiolo, Barbera, and Aussie Grenache.
The second question could be: "Does the wine have high acid?"
Answer: No – Now we’re down to just CDP, Northern Rhône Syrah, and Aussie Grenache.
The third question could be: "Does the wine have high alcohol?"
Answer: No – Voila! Grenache is eliminated, and we’re left with Northern Rhône Syrah.
At this point, if we wanted to be more precise, we could ask a few more detailed questions, such as: "Does the wine have rotundone?"
Answer: Yes – That’s a dead giveaway for Syrah from the Northern Rhône, specifically.
This exercise is incredibly simple and doesn’t even require wine in front of you. It’s all about using theory and strategic questioning to narrow down the possibilities, and it’s a great way to hone your deductive tasting skills anytime, anywhere.
Stop Relying on Blind Tasting Alone
Blind tasting alone, without a solid theoretical foundation, does you a disservice. It’s a bit like trying to memorize facts without understanding how they fit together. You can only go so far without building a strong, theoretical base. By honing your deductive tasting theory, you’ll be able to make faster, more accurate conclusions about any wine you come across.
June Group Coaching: Dive Into Deductive Tasting Theory
If you're looking to deepen your understanding of deductive tasting theory and take your skills to the next level, join me in June for group coaching!
Here's what we’ve got lined up:
Week 1: A masterclass on the theory of deductive tasting
Week 2: A Q&A support session to tackle your burning questions
Week 3: An interactive skill-building workshop to refine your techniques
Week 4: Another support session for ongoing learning and guidance
Bonus: When you join group coaching, you get access to all previous month’s masterclass and workshop recordings! This gives you the opportunity to hone in on your study skills even more, revisiting key concepts and diving deeper into areas that need more attention.
It’s the perfect opportunity to build a strong foundation and streamline your tasting skills. You’ll be amazed at how much more efficient and accurate your tastings become once you understand the theory behind it.
Comments